When Domestic Abuse Becomes Visible: The Importance of Recognising Patterns Across the Criminal Justice System

shares

 

PLEASE NOTE: THIS IS A LONG READ                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        This article explores the new Judicial Finding of Domestic Abuse under the Sentencing Act 2026, with a focus on recognising patterns of abuse, understanding risk and the importance of effective multi-agency working. It is intended for readers who wish to explore the subject in greater depth, particularly professionals working across domestic abuse, safeguarding and the criminal justice system.

 

A new judicial finding aims to improve how domestic abuse is identified and recorded at sentencing. But will better recording help professionals recognise the wider patterns of abuse, coercive control and risk that can remain hidden when incidents are viewed in isolation?

Domestic abuse does not always reveal itself in a single incident. Sometimes, the significance of what has happened only becomes clear when information from different points in time, different relationships and different organisations is brought together.

A police call-out may appear to concern an isolated argument. An earlier incident may have been recorded as criminal damage. A probation practitioner may hold information about previous behaviour, while another agency has concerns relating to a different relationship.

Individually, these pieces of information may not tell the whole story. Together, however, they may reveal repetition, escalation, coercive control or a pattern of behaviour affecting more than one victim.

This is one of the challenges in responding effectively to domestic abuse: information can exist within a system without the pattern ever becoming visible.

A significant legal development in England and Wales seeks to address part of this challenge.

What is the new Judicial Finding of Domestic Abuse?

Section 6 of the Sentencing Act 2026 introduces a formal judicial finding of domestic abuse at sentencing. The relevant provision came into force on 5 October 2026.

Where a court is passing sentence for an offence and considers that the offence involved domestic abuse carried out by the offender, it must state that view in open court. The meaning of domestic abuse is linked to the definition in the Domestic Abuse Act 2021.

This is an important development because an offence may otherwise be recorded under a particular criminal offence category without domestic abuse being consistently identifiable within the wider criminal justice system.

For example, an offence involving assault or criminal damage may have occurred in the context of domestic abuse. Recognising that context matters because the offence does not necessarily tell us everything about the behaviour surrounding it.

The new provision is intended to support more consistent identification and recording of domestic abuse within the criminal justice system, helping to improve data, offender management and the wider response to risk.

It does not create a new criminal offence, nor does the judicial finding itself introduce an automatic increase in sentence.

The change is therefore not simply about adding another entry to a record. It is about making the domestic abuse context of an offence more explicit.

Why does recognising the wider pattern matter?

In domestic abuse work, one incident rarely tells us everything we need to know about risk.

An incident may be serious in its own right, but its significance can change when viewed alongside earlier behaviour, previous reports, breaches of boundaries, threats, intimidation or a history of coercive and controlling behaviour.

Consider a hypothetical example.

A person is reported to have damaged property during a dispute with their partner. The immediate incident is investigated and dealt with.

However, information held elsewhere may indicate that police attended the same household several months earlier. Another record may refer to repeated unwanted contact following separation. A previous partner may have reported threats or controlling behaviour. There may also be concerns about escalating intimidation.

If each event is considered entirely separately, professionals may struggle to understand the overall picture.

When the information is brought together, a different set of questions emerges:

  • Is this an isolated incident or part of a repeated pattern?
  • Has the behaviour escalated over time?
  • Is there evidence of coercive or controlling behaviour?
  • Are there previous relationships or other victims that may be relevant to understanding risk?
  • What does the chronology tell us that an individual incident cannot?

The purpose of this example is not to suggest that previous allegations automatically establish guilt or that a pattern can be assumed without evidence. Rather, it demonstrates why relevant information, properly assessed and interpreted, can be essential to understanding context.

The wider pattern may be the key to understanding the risk.

The challenge of information held across different agencies

Domestic abuse responses often involve several organisations, each holding a different part of the available information.

Police may hold incident reports and call-out records. Probation may have information about an offender’s behaviour, relationships and compliance with supervision. Prisons may hold relevant information about an individual’s history and behaviour in custody. Other agencies may hold safeguarding information or concerns about particular victims.

The challenge is not always that information has never been recorded. Sometimes, the challenge is that information has not been connected, understood or acted upon in a way that reveals its wider significance.

One practitioner may know about a recent incident but not be aware of an earlier report. Another may know about previous behaviour but not recognise its relevance to the current circumstances. A third may have information about a different relationship that could help inform a broader assessment of risk.

This is why consistent recording and effective information sharing are important. They can help professionals identify relevant history and ask better questions.

However, a formal judicial finding should not be confused with a guarantee that every agency will automatically receive, access or act on every relevant piece of information. The practical value depends on how the finding is recorded, made available through appropriate systems, interpreted and used within professional decision-making.

Better recording creates an opportunity. Effective safeguarding requires that opportunity to be acted upon.

Why chronology is more than a timeline

Chronology is an essential tool in understanding domestic abuse because it allows events to be considered in relation to one another.

A chronology should do more than list dates and incidents. It should help professionals explore how behaviour develops, whether concerns are repeated, what changes over time and whether the significance of earlier events becomes clearer in light of later information.

For example, a series of apparently unrelated events may reveal:

  • Repeated attempts to monitor or control a partner.
  • Escalating threats or intimidation.
  • Continued unwanted contact following separation.
  • Repeated incidents involving the same person across different relationships.
  • Increasing frequency or seriousness of behaviour.
  • Missed opportunities to recognise and respond to emerging risk.

These patterns may not be obvious when individual events are reviewed in isolation.

Chronology also requires careful analysis. Professionals must distinguish between established facts, reported allegations, professional observations and information that remains unverified. The purpose is to develop an evidence-informed understanding of the circumstances, not to force events into a predetermined narrative.

When undertaken well, chronology can support professional curiosity, contextual understanding and more informed risk assessment.

Coercive control: looking beyond the individual incident

Coercive control is particularly important when considering patterns of domestic abuse.

Some forms of abuse are readily identifiable as individual incidents. Others become clearer through repeated behaviour over time, including monitoring, isolation, intimidation, threats, humiliation and the restriction of a person’s autonomy.

A professional who considers only the immediate offence may miss the wider context in which it occurred.

For example, a single message may appear unremarkable when read alone. Within a wider history of monitoring, threats and demands for constant contact, the same message may have a different significance.

Similarly, repeated contact after separation may need to be considered alongside earlier controlling behaviour, threats or other relevant circumstances.

This does not mean that every repeated interaction is abusive. Context, evidence, the nature of the behaviour and its impact all matter.

It does mean that professionals should be alert to the possibility that individual incidents may form part of a broader pattern of coercion and control.

The new judicial finding offers an opportunity to strengthen the visibility of domestic abuse within criminal justice records. It also reinforces the importance of understanding the circumstances surrounding an offence rather than relying exclusively on its immediate description.

What should professionals do with this information?

A formal finding is valuable only if it contributes to a more informed understanding of the case.

For professionals working across the criminal justice system, the development raises important questions.

Does the finding prompt further enquiry?

Where appropriate and proportionate, does it encourage professionals to consider relevant previous incidents, relationships and information that may inform risk?

Does it influence risk assessment?

Is the domestic abuse context considered alongside other relevant risk factors, rather than treating the current offence as an isolated event?

Does it support effective information sharing?

Can relevant information be accessed by those who need it, in accordance with applicable information-sharing arrangements, data protection requirements and professional responsibilities?

Does it help identify escalation?

Can practitioners recognise when behaviour is becoming more frequent, more serious or more controlling?

Does it encourage professional curiosity?

When a finding or record raises questions, do professionals explore its significance rather than simply acknowledging that it exists?

These are important considerations because the existence of information and the effective use of information are not the same thing.

A record can be accurate and accessible yet still fail to influence a decision if its significance is not recognised.

The hindsight challenge: what could professionals see at the time?

There is an important distinction between reviewing a case after events have unfolded and making decisions while those events are still developing.

An independent reviewer may have access to a chronology that brings together information from several years, different organisations and multiple incidents. With that overview, patterns may become much easier to identify.

A practitioner working at an earlier point in time may have had access to only a small part of that information.

It would therefore be unfair to assume that every pattern visible in hindsight should have been obvious to every professional at the time. Equally, hindsight should not prevent us from examining whether there were opportunities to ask further questions, share relevant information or respond differently.

The purpose of review and learning is to understand both what was known and what could reasonably have been known at the time.

We should ask:

  • What information did each agency hold?
  • What was available to the practitioner making the decision?
  • Was relevant information shared appropriately?
  • Were previous incidents considered alongside the current circumstances?
  • Were there indicators of escalation?
  • What might have helped professionals recognise the wider pattern earlier?

These questions move us beyond simply asking whether information was present in a record. They help us examine whether systems and professional practice supported an effective understanding of risk.

Will better recording make a difference?

The introduction of the Judicial Finding of Domestic Abuse is a welcome development in making the domestic abuse context of criminal offences more visible.

It has the potential to support more consistent recording, improve the quality of information available for analysis and help professionals consider relevant history when managing risk.

However, the impact should be assessed by looking beyond the introduction of the finding itself.

Will it lead to better-informed assessments? Will relevant information be used more effectively? Will professionals be better placed to identify repeated behaviour and escalation? Will it contribute to a more coordinated response to domestic abuse?

These are questions that implementation and ongoing evaluation will need to address.

A formal finding is not a substitute for professional judgement, comprehensive assessment or effective multi-agency working. Nor does it remove the need to listen to victims, consider their circumstances and assess the risks they face.

Instead, it should be understood as one part of a wider effort to improve how domestic abuse is recognised, recorded and responded to.

Making the pattern visible is only the beginning

Domestic abuse is not always understood through the incident that brings a person into contact with the criminal justice system.

Its significance may emerge through repetition, escalation, previous relationships and the cumulative effect of behaviour over time.

The new judicial finding creates a more formal mechanism for recording when a court considers that an offence involved domestic abuse. That is an important step towards improving visibility and consistency within the criminal justice system.

But recording is only the beginning.

The wider challenge is ensuring that relevant information is connected, interpreted and used to inform professional decisions. It requires systems that support appropriate information sharing, practitioners who remain professionally curious and assessments that consider context rather than simply counting incidents.

Ultimately, effective safeguarding depends not only on what is recorded, but on what professionals are able to understand and do with the information available to them.

The question is not simply whether domestic abuse has been recorded. It is whether the information helps us recognise the pattern, understand the risk and respond more effectively.

At DaaT Consultancy, this is central to understanding domestic abuse: looking beyond individual incidents, considering the wider context and recognising the importance of informed, evidence-based assessment.

DaaT Consultancy provides domestic abuse assessment, training and consultancy services, supporting professionals and organisations to develop a more informed understanding of domestic abuse, coercive control and risk.

This article is for professional education and information. It is not legal advice. Readers should consult the legislation and relevant official guidance for the current legal position.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *